4.9
4.9/5

Yelp, Google, Facebook: Which Review Site Is Best For A Local Business?

Picture of Daniel Flynn

Daniel Flynn

Among the most popular online directories in the United States, there is Yelp, Google & Facebook. And before we get into which one is the best review site for your business, Iโ€™d like to stress a few important points.

  • 46% of all Google searches are looking for local intent (Hubspot)
  • 97% of people learn more about a local company online than anywhere else (SEO Tribunal)
  • 78% of local mobile searches result in offline purchases (Search Engine Land)

With those statistics in mind, itโ€™s no surprise that online listings management is extremely important when it comes to local marketing. And guess what consumers (and directories) use as a key indicator of a businessโ€™ viability? Their reviews of course.

But simply knowing that online reviews are โ€œimportantโ€ doesnโ€™t mean anything unless you know which review site will put you in the best position to have a positive influence on consumers.ย 

The rest of this article will compare the pros and cons of the worldโ€™s leading review sites: Yelp, Google & Facebook so that you have a better understanding of which direction you should focus your efforts.

Yelp: The Infamous Local Business Review Site

Yelp has a bad wrap with local business owners. And no matter what the newest Nielsen study on local business directories may say, the fact that a lot of your legitimate Yelp reviews could end up being โ€œnot recommendedโ€ has a lot of businesses focusing their online reputation efforts on Google & Facebook.ย 

Granted, itโ€™s best practice to claim, verify & build out your Yelp listing for visibility purposes. However, you may want to consider routing people to your Google or Facebook listings for reasons weโ€™re about to cover.

Google My Business: Prime Exposure For Your Reputation

Perhaps the biggest strength of Google My Business over other local business directories is the prime exposure it provides on Google.ย 

Your business description, product offering & photos are all definitely important, but itโ€™s review signals that make up a big part of Googleโ€™s local pack ranking algorithm.

Therefore, if youโ€™re hoping to increase your exposure on the worldโ€™s leading search engine, then getting more positive Google reviews should be your main focus.ย 

Want to learn more about getting more positive Google reviews? Read our article here.ย 

Facebook: Social Recommendations Rather Than Star Ratings

Facebook reviews have gone the wayside of unorthodox. Now, instead of leaving a star rating, users are now asked whether they would recommend the business or not, which lends itself nicely to the platformโ€™s social nature.

Keep in mind that users can still leave a review of your business for their friends to see, but your business rating will be based on the amount of people that recommend your business rather than the traditional average star rating.ย 

The primary benefit in leveraging Facebookโ€™s social recommendations/reviews is that they can be leveraged on your business page or on the social media platform in posts.

So Whatโ€™s Our Recommendation?

You have no control over which directory your ideal customer will visit. Therefore, having optimized listings in all three directories is extremely important when it comes to improving your reach. However, if you want to double down on online visibility, we recommend routing your customers directly to your Google listing when you request reviews.ย 

Insider tip: Use an automated review generation service for maximum effectiveness because you canโ€™t expect your customers to remember unless you notify them.

To learn more about our review generation services, visit our webpage. For more articles, visit our blog.

Next Step?

The worst action is inaction! Our team is ready to find your next big move. Over 20 years of experience means we have the tools to get it done in your local market.

Share This Article!

Our Partner Network

  • 123local
  • 2findlocal
  • 8coupons
  • ABLocal
  • AllergyEats
  • AllMenus
  • AmericanTowns
  • AroundMe
  • Baidu
  • Banks.com
  • Brownbook.net
  • Central Index
  • ChamberofCommerce.com
  • CitySquares
  • CK Maps
  • Cylex
  • DexKnows
  • DoorDash
  • Dun & Bradstreet
  • eLocal
  • EZlocal
  • Find Open
  • Fliggy
  • GoLocal247
  • HERE
  • HolidayCheck
  • HostMe
  • HotFrog
  • iBegin
  • iGlobal
  • Insider Pages
  • Instagram
  • Local.com
  • LocalDatabase
  • LocalPages
  • LocalStack
  • Mafengwo
  • Mapstr
  • Menupix
  • MerchantCircle
  • My Local Services
  • n49
  • Navmii
  • NDrive
  • Opendi
  • OpenTable
  • Parent Day Out
  • Pitney Bowes
  • Pointcom
  • Postmates
  • Property Capsule
  • RetirementPlanning.net
  • SafeGraph
  • ShowMeLocal
  • Soleo
  • Superpages
  • tellows
  • TomTom
  • Top Rated Local
  • Trip.com
  • TripAdvisor
  • TrustPilot
  • Tupalo
  • Uber
  • Uber Eats
  • USCity.net
  • VotefortheBest
  • Waze
  • Where To?
  • WiserAdvisor
  • Yalwa
  • Yandex
  • YaSabe
  • YellowMoxie
  • YellowPageCity
  • YellowPagesDirectory

Want To See How You Show Up?

Tell Us Where To Send Your Report!

Run Your Free Business Report - Contact Info
Pop-up form preceding Yext Scan CTA, basic contact info

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Place Your Vision Online With Award-Winning Web Design!

Web Design - Scheduling

Set Up Your Free Account In Minutes

Make It Easier For Your Customers To Pay You!

Payments - Get Started

Set Up Your Free Account In A Matter Of Minutes

Customize Your Clover To Work The Way You Do!

Clover POS - Get Started

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Get More Positive Reviews With TAPLocal Review Management!

Review Generation - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Get A Full Tour Of Our Business Manager Dashboard!

Dashboard Demo - Scheduling

Our Packages Are Built With All Your Needs In Mind

Find Out Which Package Your Business Qualifies For!

Free Clover - Pricing

Clover POS Is The Perfect Business Companion

Find Out Which Device Is Best For Your Unique Needs!

Free Clover - Meet Clover

Pick A Time To Speak With Local Business Specialist

Claim Your Free Clover Today!

Free Clover Package - Scheduling

Create Your Free Account & Pick Your Package

Claim Your Free Clover Today!

Free Clover Package - Get Started

Want To See How You Show Up?

Tell Us About Your Business

Let's Get Started

Start Rewarding Your Customers Today!

Clover App Market - Restaurant Rewards
Pop-up form on Restaurant Rewards page

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Boost Your Business With An All In One Package!

All In One Packages - Scheduling
Pop-up form preceding All In One Packages scheduling

Ready To Boost Your Business?

Create Your Free Account To Claim Your Package!

All In One Packages - Standard

Ready To Boost Your Business?

Create Your Free Account To Claim Your Package!

All In One Packages - Builder

Ready To Boost Your Business?

Create Your Free Account To Claim Your Package!

All In One Packages - Starter

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Start Gaining Repeat Business From Your Customers Today!

Text Message Marketing - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Take Control Of How You Show Up Online Today!

Listings - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Starting Driving Hyper-Local Traffic To Your Website!

Listings - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Boost Your Facebook Ads With Hyper-Local Technology!

Facebook & Instagram - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Get Prime Exposure With Our Reach & Frequency Guarantee!

Facebook Awareness Ads - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Advertise On The World's Leading Search Engine!

Facebook Awareness Ads - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Find Out How TAPLocal Can Grow Your Business!

TAPLocal Appointment - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Get HOT Local Leads Delivered Directly To Your Phone!

Facebook Lead Ads - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Help Hungry Customers Find You When They Need To!

Listings For Food - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Drive Sales With Redeemable Offers On Facebook!

Facebook Offer Ads - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Simplify How Your Customers Pay You & Cut Processing Costs!

Payments - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Simplify Your Day-To-Day With The Perfect Point Of Sale!

Clover POS - Scheduling

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How We Grew Our Client's Business With Stellar Web Design

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Text Message Marketing For Your Business!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How We Helped Our Client Build Their Online Reputation & Get More Customers As A Result!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage Google Ads For Business Growth

Read A Client Success Story

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Facebook for Growth!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Facebook Offer Ads for Growth!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Facebook Lead Ads for Growth!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Facebook Awareness Ads for Growth!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Facebook Click Ads To Grow Your Business

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How We Increased Our Client's Online Visibility & Got Him More Leads!

Get Your Web Design eBook!

Learn What Separates A Winning Website From The Losing Ones

Get Your Free SMS Marketing eBook!

Learn How To Turn New Purchases Into Your Most Loyal Customers

Get Your Reputation Management eBook!

Learn How To Build Your Online Reputation & Get More Paying Customers

Get Your Free Ebook Today

Learn How To Audit Your Merchant Statement And Cut Your Costs

Get Your Google Ads eBook!

Learn How To Convert Web Traffic Into Revenue

Get Your Facebook Ads eBook Today!

Learn How To Advertise On The World’s Biggest Stage

Can Google's Crawlers Understand Your Site?

Find Out If Your Website Has Schema Markup

Schema Markup - Contact Info

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Payments Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Payments Consultation Awaits

Let's Create Your Free Account

Claim Your Free Clover Today!

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Get Your Business Listings eBook!

Learn How To Get Found By Consumers Who Are Searching For A Product Or Service That You Offer