4.9
4.9/5

3 Red Flags To Look For In A Digital Marketing Agency

Picture of Daniel Flynn

Daniel Flynn

Healthy relationships are built on trust. Client-agency relationships are no different. As a business owner, you need to surround yourself with individuals and organizations that want you to succeed.

At our agency, we repeatedly tell clients that when they succeed, we succeed. This philosophy is central to our corporate identity, which is why we value transparency and focus on the results of our efforts.

Unfortunately, most agencies do not internalize this way of thinking. In fact, most agencies spend a majority of their time convincing their clients of the value that they provide rather than actually providing it. As you can imagine, demonstrating value that is not present requires dishonesty.

The rest of this article seeks to explain three red flags to be cautious of when working with a digital marketing agency.

1. Black hat SEO tactics

Website traffic is a key metric that business owners and marketers alike use to determine the performance of a webpage or site. Due to the pressure on agencies to deliver results, some may buy clicks and traffic for their clients.

If this is done under an agreement with the client, then alright. Using bought traffic to improve domain authority is an option for business owners. However, I do not advise it as a viable option as it can lead to penalties from Google, netting a loss for domain authority.

Nevertheless, some agencies will buy traffic for a client without them knowing, which is neither transparent or ethical.

Although it is difficult to detect ‘bought’ traffic, you should have regular discussions with your agency about your traffic and traffic sources. In addition, you should see conversion rate as a key performance indicator.

2. Unauthentic reviews on agency’s website

This second red flag is more commonplace than you think. Fabricating customer reviews is a common practice for most business. However, it gives business owners unrealistic expectations. In addition, some agencies will only have reviews on their own website. The reason for doing so is having control over the reviews that consumers can see. If you only allow reviews on your website, you can manually delete the ones that are not favorable.

As a business owner, you may not want to partner with a company that does not value the authentic opinion of their customers as a primary component of their image. On the contrary, you should look for a company that values authenticity. Furthermore, the way an agency conducts their own marketing & branding efforts is a key indicator of how they will conduct yours.

All of our reviews are posted by real customers in public forums. Therefore, you can see them for yourself right now if you’d like. The testimonials posted on our website are directly sourced from those public forums.

We implement the same reputation management practices on which we coach our clients.

3. Guarantees

Some agencies make guarantees that they cannot deliver. If you have read our blog, you may recall our explanation of how digital marketing success requires time. The amount of time effective digital marketing requires depends on a variety of factors, including the industry’s competitiveness. Therefore, you are setting yourself up for disappointment when buying into guarantees.

On the contrary, what an agency should commit to in their client-agency relationships are transparency, dedication, and the implementation of best practices, which are the promises that we make to our clients.

To see more information about our services and how we can help your business grow through local marketing efforts, visit our homepage

Next Step?

The worst action is inaction! Our team is ready to find your next big move. Over 20 years of experience means we have the tools to get it done in your local market.

Share This Article!

Our Partner Network

  • 123local
  • 2findlocal
  • 8coupons
  • ABLocal
  • AllergyEats
  • AllMenus
  • AmericanTowns
  • AroundMe
  • Baidu
  • Banks.com
  • Brownbook.net
  • Central Index
  • ChamberofCommerce.com
  • CitySquares
  • CK Maps
  • Cylex
  • DexKnows
  • DoorDash
  • Dun & Bradstreet
  • eLocal
  • EZlocal
  • Find Open
  • Fliggy
  • GoLocal247
  • HERE
  • HolidayCheck
  • HostMe
  • HotFrog
  • iBegin
  • iGlobal
  • Insider Pages
  • Instagram
  • Local.com
  • LocalDatabase
  • LocalPages
  • LocalStack
  • Mafengwo
  • Mapstr
  • Menupix
  • MerchantCircle
  • My Local Services
  • n49
  • Navmii
  • NDrive
  • Opendi
  • OpenTable
  • Parent Day Out
  • Pitney Bowes
  • Pointcom
  • Postmates
  • Property Capsule
  • RetirementPlanning.net
  • SafeGraph
  • ShowMeLocal
  • Soleo
  • Superpages
  • tellows
  • TomTom
  • Top Rated Local
  • Trip.com
  • TripAdvisor
  • TrustPilot
  • Tupalo
  • Uber
  • Uber Eats
  • USCity.net
  • VotefortheBest
  • Waze
  • Where To?
  • WiserAdvisor
  • Yalwa
  • Yandex
  • YaSabe
  • YellowMoxie
  • YellowPageCity
  • YellowPagesDirectory

Want To See How You Show Up?

Tell Us Where To Send Your Report!

Run Your Free Business Report - Contact Info
Pop-up form preceding Yext Scan CTA, basic contact info

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Place Your Vision Online With Award-Winning Web Design!

Web Design - Scheduling

Set Up Your Free Account In Minutes

Make It Easier For Your Customers To Pay You!

Payments - Get Started

Set Up Your Free Account In A Matter Of Minutes

Customize Your Clover To Work The Way You Do!

Clover POS - Get Started

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Get More Positive Reviews With TAPLocal Review Management!

Review Generation - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Get A Full Tour Of Our Business Manager Dashboard!

Dashboard Demo - Scheduling

Our Packages Are Built With All Your Needs In Mind

Find Out Which Package Your Business Qualifies For!

Free Clover - Pricing

Clover POS Is The Perfect Business Companion

Find Out Which Device Is Best For Your Unique Needs!

Free Clover - Meet Clover

Pick A Time To Speak With Local Business Specialist

Claim Your Free Clover Today!

Free Clover Package - Scheduling

Create Your Free Account & Pick Your Package

Claim Your Free Clover Today!

Free Clover Package - Get Started

Want To See How You Show Up?

Tell Us About Your Business

Let's Get Started

Start Rewarding Your Customers Today!

Clover App Market - Restaurant Rewards
Pop-up form on Restaurant Rewards page

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Boost Your Business With An All In One Package!

All In One Packages - Scheduling
Pop-up form preceding All In One Packages scheduling

Ready To Boost Your Business?

Create Your Free Account To Claim Your Package!

All In One Packages - Standard

Ready To Boost Your Business?

Create Your Free Account To Claim Your Package!

All In One Packages - Builder

Ready To Boost Your Business?

Create Your Free Account To Claim Your Package!

All In One Packages - Starter

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Start Gaining Repeat Business From Your Customers Today!

Text Message Marketing - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Take Control Of How You Show Up Online Today!

Listings - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Starting Driving Hyper-Local Traffic To Your Website!

Listings - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Boost Your Facebook Ads With Hyper-Local Technology!

Facebook & Instagram - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Get Prime Exposure With Our Reach & Frequency Guarantee!

Facebook Awareness Ads - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Advertise On The World's Leading Search Engine!

Facebook Awareness Ads - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Find Out How TAPLocal Can Grow Your Business!

TAPLocal Appointment - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Get HOT Local Leads Delivered Directly To Your Phone!

Facebook Lead Ads - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Help Hungry Customers Find You When They Need To!

Listings For Food - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Drive Sales With Redeemable Offers On Facebook!

Facebook Offer Ads - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Simplify How Your Customers Pay You & Cut Processing Costs!

Payments - Scheduling

Pick A Time To Speak With A Local Business Expert

Simplify Your Day-To-Day With The Perfect Point Of Sale!

Clover POS - Scheduling

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How We Grew Our Client's Business With Stellar Web Design

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Text Message Marketing For Your Business!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How We Helped Our Client Build Their Online Reputation & Get More Customers As A Result!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage Google Ads For Business Growth

Read A Client Success Story

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Facebook for Growth!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Facebook Offer Ads for Growth!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Facebook Lead Ads for Growth!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Facebook Awareness Ads for Growth!

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How To Leverage The Power of Facebook Click Ads To Grow Your Business

Read A Client Success Story!

Learn How We Increased Our Client's Online Visibility & Got Him More Leads!

Get Your Web Design eBook!

Learn What Separates A Winning Website From The Losing Ones

Get Your Free SMS Marketing eBook!

Learn How To Turn New Purchases Into Your Most Loyal Customers

Get Your Reputation Management eBook!

Learn How To Build Your Online Reputation & Get More Paying Customers

Get Your Free Ebook Today

Learn How To Audit Your Merchant Statement And Cut Your Costs

Get Your Google Ads eBook!

Learn How To Convert Web Traffic Into Revenue

Get Your Facebook Ads eBook Today!

Learn How To Advertise On The World’s Biggest Stage

Can Google's Crawlers Understand Your Site?

Find Out If Your Website Has Schema Markup

Schema Markup - Contact Info
small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Payments Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Payments Consultation Awaits

Let's Create Your Free Account

Claim Your Free Clover Today!

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

small_c_popup.png

Let's have a chat

Your Free Local Marketing Consultation Awaits

Get Your Business Listings eBook!

Learn How To Get Found By Consumers Who Are Searching For A Product Or Service That You Offer